How reporters investigated pink slime news in small town Virginia
The Shenandoah Valley city of Winchester, Virginia, is like many small communities in America — it’s lost its journalists.
In Virginia, 80 counties are now considered news deserts, with either one credible local news source or none. The local daily, The Winchester Star, recently cut staff, and the TV station has left town. Even the local university’s journalism program shut down.
Enter the Winchester Gazette — and the town’s biggest mystery. The Gazette website launched in 2023 as a free alternative to the 130-year-old daily.
The Gazette publishes daily stories about crime, government meetings and community events, some with the scent of AI text. It boasted of being the first website in the country to call the 2024 presidential election for Donald Trump. By one estimate, it had a monthly audience of about 11,000 visitors.
Unlike traditional newsrooms, the Gazette’s stories carried no bylines. Its reporters, editors and owners remained obscured. Many community members had no idea about the who, what, when, where and why behind it.
Our newsroom knew nothing about the Gazette. The Virginia Center for Investigative Journalism at WHRO is a small nonprofit covering statewide stories for the public media station in Norfolk. One quarter of the newsroom is writing this narrative.
We received an email tip about a possible story in Winchester, and I forwarded it to two trusted freelancers, Jaysun Silver and Laura Thompson.
The email tip led nowhere, but days later it turned up almost verbatim in the Winchester Gazette. Silver and Thompson wanted to know more about a site that would publish a rumor, whose editorial policies were at odds with mainstream journalism.
We saw more than a local story. The decline of local reporting, the ease of AI content creation, a community conditioned on free content and wanting local news – that’s fertile ground to plant an opaque, partisan news site. This could happen anywhere.
We had long conversations with Jaysun and Laura. I gave them a template for a project proposal. What’s the story in one sentence? What’s the potential impact? Why does it matter to readers? We had a call every week.
Those weekly talks kept everyone focused, allowed us to prune dead ends, connect with sources and push ahead as the reporting led us in new directions.
Jaysun and Laura FOIA’d city emails for correspondence with the Gazette. They found more than a dozen stories on the Gazette website labeled “exclusive interviews.” They called the subjects. Several told VCIJ they had never spoken with the Gazette, yet were quoted extensively.
They found a former Gazette reporter, who shared her contract with the news site. The agreement included a non-disclosure clause that called for up to a $100,000 penalty for revealing the operations of the Gazette.
The former reporter sat down with Laura and Jaysun. “Screw this non-disclosure stuff,” she told them.
She shared texts, emails and documents, including instructions from an editor that her most important job was to go to crash scenes and get personal information from “the party not at fault.”
A local car-crash beat? That, too, was odd.
A Gazette group text showed the phone numbers of an editor and a reporter with area codes in Mexico and the Philippines. The Gazette’s owner was a Virginia company.
A search of state corporation commission records showed the company’s “incorporator” and “secretary” was a 90-year-old relative of a Winchester personal injury attorney.
The reporting accelerated.
The personal injury attorney, Carroll “Beau” Correll, chairs the Winchester Republican Committee and the city planning commission. He was appointed to a state commission by then-Gov. Glenn Youngkin, a Republican. The reporters contacted Correll and received brief statements saying he had no ownership or editorial control over the Gazette.
Jaysun and Laura then spent several days in Winchester, meeting sources, attending a planning commission to try to speak to Correll in person, and reviewing public records in the courthouse.
Emails to the Gazette were initially answered by a woman known as “Sofia Alvarez.” VCIJ messages sent to the number were not returned. Later, the reporters’ emails to the Gazette were answered with unsigned statements. These statements did not answer direct questions about whether AI was used for stories, and they said the company stood by its reporting. Our offers to meet in person were ignored.
An editor in the Gazette text chain had an area code based in the Philippines. Messages to that number were not returned.
The draft came together after several months of reporting. It had to have a section that broadened the investigation from a small-town mystery into a cautionary story about what happens in a news vacuum.
We went through weeks of fact-checking, editing and revisiting sources.
In the final weeks before publication, we learned perhaps the most astounding fact -- the Gazette produced 6,000 stories in three years, without a discernible newsroom or collection of journalists. Regardless of its quality, a news site producing that much content was bound to gather a local audience.
The story published in early October and drew a large online audience. Jaysun and Laura appeared on a local Fox TV affiliate. Public media stations across Virginia ran the investigation.
Jaysun returned to Winchester to revisit sources and follow up on new leads. Local elected leaders from both parties have called for Correll to resign his public positions.
A few days after we published the investigation, I spoke with the managing editor of the Winchester Star. She asked if they could publish our story in their Friday print edition.
Of course, I said. Just save me a few copies.