Cart 0 $0.00
IRE favicon

Do universities play a role in student suicides?

By Nikhila Henry, The Times of India

Photo from the The Struggle Committee for Justice for Mudasir Kamran Facebook page

Can the dead talk? In rare cases they do.

Mudassir Kamran, a 25-year-old Kashmiri student hanged himself in a single bed hostel room at English and Foreign Languages University (EFLU), Hyderabad, India on March 2, 2013.

A day before, the scholar was summoned to a nearby police station and questioned on counts of “harassing” a fellow male student, Vasim Salim. Some administrative staff of the university worked with the police in this round of questioning.

While this at first seemed to be what some consider a “routine” case of suicide, Kamran’s death had more to it. Reporting his death and the role university officials and police played in it led me to a series of stories on student suicides happening across the city, for reasons other than individual woes.

My question was: Do educational institutions drive students to kill themselves?  

What made Kamran’s story out of the ordinary were two aspects of it which I chose not to ignore. First, he, a Muslim student from Kashmir was summoned by the police a fortnight after twin bomb blasts rocked the city, killing and injuring many, a time when Muslim youth were being picked up randomly for questioning.

Second, the administration and the police issued several off-the-record statements to the press about Kamran’s character, branding him a gay troublemaker even though he had not come out of the closet when alive, leading to suspicion that both parties had something to hide. And they did.

Kamran’s version of events came to me as I paid attention to every detail of the developing agitation lead by scores of students on the varsity campus, building trust among many who were fighting what seemed to be a losing battle. 

One evening, a phone call from a trusted source hinted at Kamran’s correspondence with the administration soon before his death. I used letters Kamran wrote in response to the harassment allegations to report on negligence of the varsity heads. As both the administration and the police had chosen not to talk about the existence of these letters, the story I wrote revealed a version of the deceased student who badly wanted someone to hear his side of the conflict. A close look at each of the letters revealed that Kamran had defended his case politely, yet with conviction.

This story changed the direction of reporting related to the suicide. Kamran’s death was no more just a “case.” It became the story of a real person, one who was not offered help when he needed it.

Mudassir Kamran’s story did not end there, as the police chose to hunt down students who were protesting for him. In what seemed to be a clear case of profiling, internal police records I procured revealed efforts of the city police and the administration to close Kamran’s case by blaming students and some faculty members for the unrest, trivializing the very cause of his death.

What made the series a success was its spiraling effect. It gave me the chance to write on what can be broadly called institutional lapses that lead to student suicides. On university campuses in a city where a heterogeneous population of students come from various socioeconomic backgrounds (including those from various races, castes and communities), no mechanism was in place to address their individual problems or help them cope with the system. Moreover, no effort was made to change or revive the existing academic system to suit the needs of these students.

This report was admitted in the Andhra Pradesh High Court as a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) and the court ordered a probe into all suicide cases, including that of Kamran. The court went on to take steps to ensure that a meaningful process be put in place to prevent student suicide.   

As things stand now, the struggle committee set up by students demanding a probe into the death of Mudassir Kamran is still functional, more than a year after his death. No ex-gratia – a form of compensation payment – was made to the student’s family.

I am continuing to report on student suicides caused by administrative lapses, harassment and discrimination based on race, class and caste. The most recent investigative story on an institutional suicide was that of Madari Venkatesh, a Dalit (lower caste) student at the University of Hyderabad, another centrally-funded varsity, who killed himself following alleged caste harassment by teachers.  

Nikhila Henry is a principal correspondent with the Times of India in Hyderabad, where she covers education. Henry specializes in conflict reporting, covering communal clashes and sectarian violence. She has reported extensively on issues of harassment and related conflicts within modern educational spaces.

Massachusetts is facing a little noticed breakdown in democracy. More than one-third of seats on state boards and commissions are either vacant or occupied by people whose terms expired months or years ago, according to a Globe review last week. In all, the Globe counted 919 vacancies and 867 holdover members on nearly 700 boards that oversee everything from a cranberry research center to a commission studying postpartum depression.

The State Police kept secret an evidence-handling scandal that erupted in 2011 at a bustling barracks in Westchester County in which drugs and other evidence were lost, leading to botched prosecutions, the retirement of two senior investigators and the forced resignation of a trooper accused of lying to internal affairs investigators.

The only person arrested in the investigation was a nurse who is married to a former senior investigator.

A major Pennsylvania health-care system invited New York to participate in a long-term, extensive study of shale-gas drilling's human impacts, but a partnership never materialized.

The February 2013 invitation from a Geisinger Health System administrator was among thousands of pages of documents recently released by the state Department of Health regarding its ongoing review of hydraulic fracturing.

The trove of documents includes dozens of outside studies on fracking, as well as some limited correspondence with state officials. In one 2012 letter, New York's top environmental regulator declined a meeting with famed consumer advocate and third-party presidential candidate Ralph Nader.

When former Milwaukee County jail guard Aron Arvelo was charged recently with two felonies accusing him of secretly recording female co-workers, it wasn't the first time he had run into trouble for harassing women.

Just 2 1/2 years earlier, officials tried unsuccessfully to fire Arvelo after he was caught stalking a co-worker. But a five-member citizen panel refused to follow the recommendation, putting Arvelo back in his old job.

The Air Force has spent tens of millions of dollars over the past two years correcting problems with its premier jet fighter - issues that Capt. Joshua Wilson helped expose by speaking up, both to his bosses and on national television.

Since then, Wilson's career as an F-22 Raptor pilot has stalled. A member of the Virginia Air National Guard's 149th Fighter Squadron, Wilson hasn't been permitted to fly the jet since early 2012. He's fighting disciplinary actions that he sees as retribution for going public.

From January 2011 through last month, the Massachusetts Legislature enacted 945 bills – just 5 percent of nearly 17,600 proposed. Only New York, New Jersey, and Minnesota passed a smaller percentage of proposed legislation in that time, according to data compiled from the LexisNexis website Statenet.com.

Earlier this year, three women reported that Iowa City drivers — two from unmarked cabs — made unwanted sexual advances, and police are investigating. The assaults show another form of danger haunting weekends in home to the University of Iowa when alcohol flows and carefree moments make students easy marks.

Many city officials agree that changes to taxi regulations would reduce chances that a cab ride will end in tragedy.

One city manager is guaranteed to earn 15 percent more than his second-highest paid employee. Another was granted up to $2,500 in public funds to pay for lawyers or other experts to advise him on his employment contract.

The $260,000 base salary awarded to incoming Carlsbad City Manager Steven Sarkozy prompted U-T Watchdog to revisit the compensation paid to city administrators in San Diego County.

General Motors waited years to recall nearly 335,000 Saturn Ions for power steering failures despite getting thousands of consumer complaints and more than 30,000 warranty repair claims, according to government documents released Saturday.

109 Lee Hills Hall, Missouri School of Journalism   |   221 S. Eighth St., Columbia, MO 65201   |   573-882-2042   |   info@ire.org   |   Privacy Policy
crossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram
My cart
Your cart is empty.

Looks like you haven't made a choice yet.